Wednesday, January 24, 2007

Cunningham, H (2005) Children and Childhood in Western Society Since 1500. Great Britain: Pearson Education Limited

Cunningham discusses the changes over the years, beginning in America where children were being made to look like science projects and parents were advised not to have an intimate or loving contact with their children. But rather John Watson suggested that parents should treat their children “as though they were young adults.” (183-184) This then changed after the Second World War as many stated that this treatment of children would play a large role in their attitudes later on in life. “Parents were (now) being advised to enjoy parenting rather than to look on it as an intimidating scientific task.” (84)

N.B Personally I do not agree with treating infants like young adults they are entitled to enjoy their childhood and be able to experience love and fun. Reading the part of this text caused me to become quite angry and upset about the way children used to be seen as guinea pigs and ruled in a fascist way.

Cunningham continues to say that the child has changed from being a “productive role within the economy” to “ a new role as consumers.” (185) He goes onto claim that this therefore altered the opinion of the parent and as a result, parents decided to have less children as they were not being valued as a contribution to the family economy. Instead, they valued more individually and for “emotional reasons”. This therefore created a rise in a child’s confidence when they were older and were able to contribute to the family’s economy. (85)
Woodhead. M, Light. P and Carr, R. (1991) Growing up in a Changing Society. London: Routledge

Barbara Tizard (Chapter 4) Source: E. Lloyd, A. Phoenix and A. Woollett (1991) Social Construction of Motherhood, London: Sage

Methodology: Looked into the work and research carried out by John Bowlby who “believes that the root of personality development lies in the child’s early relationships with the mother.” (61)

The lack of intimacy and loving relationship between a mother and a child can have a large effect on the infant’s development and he has related and carried out this theory on a “study of young thieves” (61)

N.B Look at work on John Bowlby

K. Alison Clarke-Stewart (Chapter 5) Source: American Psychologist (1989) 44 (2): 266-73

Clarke-Stewart talks about the dramatic increase of mothers going back into full-time employment after having children.

Mother-infant relationship the theories that surround this area – mainly concerning with Freud and his views on child/separation from the mother and the effect on the child’s development. Stewart states clearly that although research has shown that children still prefer their mother’s attachment rather than that of a care-taker’s, however her question is “whether the quality of their attachment is as good” is as “emotionally secure” as those attachments that have formed through a child and a parent who has been the only caregiver in the infant’s life.” (79)

Methodology: Stewart began to research this through bringing together data from all studies that have been carried out on child’s attachment to their mothers.
The Strange Situation: (80) Where the child is left in an unknown room with an unknown woman and toys that are unfamiliar and not of their own. The study is carried out to see if children react differently when the mother comes back into the room. Those who have been in day care are supposed to be less likely to be affected by the mother’s return and will quite happily play with the unfamiliar toys and be comforted by the stranger of another woman. Where as the child who is constantly cared for by the mother will want to be reunited with her as soon as she returns to the room. Yet, a disadvantage of this situation is the stress that can be placed on the child, as it is an unusual environment for them to be in.
Clarke-Stewart and Fein (1983) claimed that quite often researchers have discovered that children who attend infant day care have higher intelligence. Tests that have been carried out on infants aged between 18 months and 5 years showed that those who had been placed in day care/nurseries received higher scores on intelligence tests then those who had not. (84)
She goes onto talk about the varied factors that may affect the child’s attachment: (85-87):

1.) Day care factors – “the type, stability or quality of day care experienced by the infants.”
2.) Child factors – the individual; the different characteristics of the child.
3.) Family factors – the mother as an individual whether she had intended to stay at home and then realised or decided that she could not cope with motherhood. Another example given is the stress of dealing with “two full-time jobs – work and motherhood – which would lead to more rejection of every additional burden, including the baby.” (87) This could be extended to having to deal with household tasks and chores as well.




Sources I would like to get hold of:

Ramey, C.T, Dorval, B and Baker-Ward, L (1983) “Group day care and socially disadvantaged families: effects on the child and the family” in S. Kilmer (ed) Advances in Early Education and Day care (Vol 3, 69-106) Greenwich, Conn: JAI Press

Clarke-Stewart, K. A and Fein, G. G (1983) “Early Childhood Programs” in P. H Mussen (ed) Handbook of Child Psychology: Vol.2 Infancy and Developmental Psychobiology. New York: Wiley
Methodology of Elkind

The research that Elkind carried out was through looking at past assignments over the past ten years. He considers child development to be a “broad domain” which deals with results found in the classroom as well as the home. Elkind talks about a “two-directional approach” to this area. Practical as well as theory, the research in Elkind’s book contains both “research and theory to practice” and “practice to research and theory” (Introduction ix-x)

Chapter 2 in Elkind considers day care in America (22-23) – Similar to my own experience of working in day care, the staff at all levels, whether they be managers or not, enjoy their jobs and maintain “an enthusiastic” approach. Yet, many of the staff are young and although enjoy working in this type of environment do not see it as a full-time or life-long career. Therefore it is hard “getting and keeping competent staff” (22). Many staff members in this particular nursery, similar to those I have worked in found that with staff being so young, they choose to stay only for a couple of years before finding something new. For many, this involves moving onto higher education. However, the low pay also plays a large role in the staff constantly leaving. The salary of a care-worker is not much at all and although staff love the job and working with the children, the pay is not enough to keep them. This seems to be the case in both England and America.
The Struggle…….

Well it has been awhile since I have been here! I have found it extremely hard to get back into my Independent Study and I have to admit that I have put it to the back when it has come to my other work. Over the weekend and this week, however I sat down just to read over some books and the work that I have already done. This helped a lot as it has placed me back into the motion of wanting to work on it. Now, I do not know why I did not do this before I was afraid of the Independent Study but once again I have had to tell myself that it is not as big as I believe it to be.

I have progressed in my ideas and feel that I have something to work with at the moment. As before I was worrying that I was not sure where I was going and I had placed a mental block in the pathway. However, now I feel I know where I am going with my Independent Study and this is why I wish to meet up with Clive on Friday to discuss my plans!

Monday, December 04, 2006

Seeing Clive………..

Today, I saw Clive and expanding on the summarising that I am making of the research I am reading, I am going to create an extra column and make notes of the types of methodologies that the authors/researchers are using when making their reports. I will then wish to include this as a section under my Literature Review and possibly when I come to carry out my methodology, I will be able to see what ideas were used and relate them to my Independent Study. This will therefore enable me to move into my methodology section smoothly, allowing my report to flow and for an obvious link to be seen between the two parts.
Elkind, D 1979 The Child and Society, New York: Oxford University Press

Looks at the affects that social change has on a child’s development. How adults consider social change and the way their attitudes have an affect on children.

The ways, in which generations consider themselves, youths of today are considered as “wilder, freer, more boisterous, and more disrespectful” (1979: 4). Older generations do not remember themselves as being this ‘bad’ when they were youths.
Elkind describes three adult illusions; generational illusion is described as above.

Immediacy illusion, which looks again at the difference between adults and youths, an example given on page 4-5, adults see waiting in a queue or waiting in traffic as a long time, it seems to take an age. Yet, when reflecting on their own lives and their years of growing up, the time seems to have gone so quickly, with the older generation as well, Elkind talks about “The sense of urgency” that time is running out and that something needs to be done now. Adults may believe that youths share this idea. However, Elkind states that youths do not have this sense of urgency. They understand and appreciate the dangers of pollution, global warming, but they do not see the urgency to act and do something about it now!
This links in with the generational illusion as the older generation believe that the younger generation should have the same priorities when, according to Elkind it is not essential that they do.

Homogeneity illusion – Being stereotypical about youths, grouping them as all being the same. When in actual fact, youths are just as diverse as adults. For example on page 6, there are youths who attend church as part of their social life, in comparison to youths who hang out down the park or at the local bowling alley.
The media having an effect on the stereotypical view of youths, as the majority of the time, youths are only talked about as being one type or another. There are no variations or talk about the different types.

Social change affects adults and those adults that are parents then pass this affect onto their children.

The change in schools, “schools too have focused more and more upon making academic achievements, rather than personal adjustment, their primary goal.” (1979: 7). A result of this is the child having to become “competent at an early age”. This happens in both academic areas such as Mathematics, Science and English as well as in sports and outdoor activities, Elkind phrases it as creating “a miniature adult”. This then leads to competition and with this comes the positive and the negative, the failure as well as the success. Many parents urge their children to compete without considering the affects and frustrations it may be causing the child.

Elkind believes that the child’s wants and needs, that were always considered to come above a parents’ is now changing. He names the “child-centred approach to child rearing is rapidly disappearing” (1979: 8). With mother’s going to work instead of staying at home with their children, in this case, Elkind sees the child’s needs and wants becoming second to the parents’. This then leads onto the child, having to gain “emotional independence” at an early stage. A link is then made to divorce, and the divorce rate having increased over the years, and the fact that parents are willing to separate if they are unhappy, not staying together for the sake of the family or for the children.

The use of frames between parents and children, the “rules, expectancies and understandings that operate in repetitive social situations.” (1979: 79) The way frames are formed and established through a child’s social interaction. How these frames vary and differ within different social settings. For example, the lunchtime period at a child’s school has a different frame and a more relaxed ruling than the setting within a classroom.

Friday, December 01, 2006

This week..........

This week, I have been concentrating on other areas of study and trying to get an essay completed before Christmas, so that I do not have to worry about it over the holidays and can concentrate on my Independent Study.
Over the weekend, I am going to continue with my reading and researching, in order to build up a Literature Review and I can write a draft and blog it over the Christmas, so that in January I have completed this section.
I am hoping to have a meeting with Clive on Monday 4th December, so that I can tell him what stage I think I am at and my new focus of the Independent Study!!!

Actually feeling excited about the Independent Study again!!!!! At this stage anyway!!!!

Friday, November 24, 2006

Morgan, P 1996 Who Needs Parents? The effects of childcare and early education on children in Britain and the USA. London: IEA Health and Welfare Unit

Looks at the idea of third-party childcare as being good and beneficial for the child. States that it is a hard issue to discuss as many get infuriated when questioning that day care/nurseries is “better” or at least “ harmless” compared to “parental care”.

Advantages
Childcare is seen as something that can benefit a child in preparing them for school and in a wider view into adulthood.

Looks into childcare as an Economic Necessity but not the same as Giddens; but rather employers need women to work to prevent the “shrinking numbers in the young workforce” (Edwina Currie, The Times).
Also, children create labour such as clothes and food, which increases jobs and employment. Childcare therefore creates economic advantages as they allow parents to go back to work and also provides jobs such as nursery workers/assistants, teachers, kitchen staff etc.

Page 3 Quotes

“It increases both the labour supply and the demand for labour”.

“Childcare is the most prominent way in which the personal services and functions performed by families are meant to enter the cash economy”.

“Industrialisation necessarily led to the dependence of all social life, and human interrelatedness, upon the market or ‘social production’ so that the population no longer relies upon organisations like family, kin or community.”

Disadvantages (Page 81)
Children that get placed into day care/ nurseries do not grow up with a good relationship with their mothers and this leads to stress and problems later on in life. Childcare is said to lower depression for mothers, but this is related to financial issues rather than actually caring for the child. The mother knows that if she works, the family income will increase and therefore the chance of depression decreases. “Poor parents make anxious parents”.

The changing of roles between the mother and the father and the impact on the family – either sex resulting in depression as they feel their stereotypical role is being questioned.

Chapter 8 deals with the idea of attachment between child and parent and the similarities/differences between the bond created between the two, if a child is placed into day care/nurseries or not – “Strange Situation” (Page 86-87)

Chapter 9 (Page 90)
“Childcare affects children, so employment affects parenting”.

Attachment depends on the following:

  • The mother and fathers work patterns
  • The parents’ attitudes and behaviour towards their children
  • The family environment as a whole – as a family unit/in a home environment
  • The child’s behaviour
  • The care that the child is given:
    1 By parents
    2 Who is left to look after the child when parents’ are away?

Since women have increased in numbers within the “labour force” over the last century, it is extremely common to have both parents in full-time employment.
“The amount of ‘total contact time’ between parents and children, is calculated to have dropped 40 per cent for the USA during the last quarter century”. (Page 90)
Therefore, the time spent between the child and the mother/father is/has reduced dramatically. It is hard for parents to not treat their children like objects and to actually form relationships with them, if they are not around that often. If the only time parents get to see and play with their children is the evening when the child is meant to be sleeping it is harder to create and strengthen relationships.

The feeling of guilt within the mother (page 93)

Page 121 – Economic Issues
Children being the workers and employment of the future/ providers of the future, therefore parents should give time to make attachments with their children, as they will be the ones that are in control in the next generation. If they are all suffering from stress and depression due to lack attachment with their parents, then ‘we’ are all to suffer!










Thursday, November 23, 2006

Lakoff, G 2004 Don’t think of an Elephant! Know your Values and Frame the Debate. Vermont: Chelsea Green Publishing

Theory and Application. Framing 101: How to take back Public Discourse

Relating family to politics – the need for democracy, equal rights in a family. Language used such as “Founding Fathers” and sending our “sons” to war. As humans we link politics/universal views to family values.

James Dobson ‘Dare to Discipline’ – Strict Father Model (Dictatorship) – Another link between family and right-wing politics (page 61).
Father tells not asks
President tells not asks

The Nurturant Parent – gender neutral – democracy; both parents equally responsible. Honesty, open-two way communication is fundamental in family as well as in a community, country – progressive values.
Page 14 – Six basic types of progressives. All of which are examples of the nurturant parent morality.

Page 46 (Chapter 3) – What’s in a word? Plenty if it’s marriage
Marriage – the connotations of the word. Life-long relationship, a partnership, family, vows, a home.
Why is same-sex marriage then frowned upon, as all of the above can be both hetero as well as homosexual?
Lakoff discusses sex being involved with marriage and many do not favour the idea of gays or lesbians having sex.
The connotations of same-sex marriage and gay marriage – same meaning but one sounds slightly sordid and represents an “irresponsible lifestyle” whilst the other softens the view that many have about gay marriages. There is something about getting the word into the English language and using it more regularly so that it becomes common and therefore the idea of same-sex marriages will become known more in our culture and society as well as our language.
Refers back to the Strict Father Model – they agree with only heterosexual marriage
Father = Leader:

  • Role model to sons
  • For daughters a model of what a man should be

On the other hand, the Nurturant Parent Model (two equal parents – democracy) stands for: (Page 48)

  • Freedom
  • Openness - Strong Progressive Politics
  • Cooperation
  • Community Development
  • Fairness


Nurture children, teach children to nurture others. Although still considers marriage to be between man and woman, it does consider and does not rule out same-sex marriage. Strict Father Families follow tradition and are threatened by same-sex marriages.
Civil Unions allow for an economic unit (a family and a partnership) to be created. However, “gay activists” want their marriages to be accepted like a heterosexual marriage in a church so that they are able to represent their love and be treated with a “sense of normality”; the relationship between politics and personal freedom, under the law “equality includes social and cultural as well as material benefits” (page 49). When one thinks of the two aspects, marriage and family the initial thoughts are concerned with love, care and commitment not economic fairness.

The representation of the media – the way reporter phrases their questions to receive the most interesting and controversial answer. Lakoff talks about the ability to reframe, reframing a question can give a completely different answer.

Should be noted that this is an American resource.

Monday, November 20, 2006

A change in direction….

After reading Giddens and Lakoff, I have decided to focus upon the idea of children within society of today and how the idea of a family unit and the reasoning for having children has changed over time. Specifically, in relation to the idea of a family being seen as an economic unit and the number of children within a family decreasing over time.

I know this focus has differed from my original aim, however I see it as progress rather than a complete change. The process of my Independent Study so far has led me to take this path of direction and I feel I will be able to include and discuss this positive progress within my final piece of my Independent Study.

Books to read and summarise:
  • Elkind, D 1979 The Child and Society. New York: Open University Press

  • Woodhead, M, Light, P & Carr, R 1991 Growing up in a Changing Society. London: Routledge

  • Cunningham, H 2005 Children and Childhood in Western Society Since 1500. Great Britain: Pearson Education Limited

  • Morgan, P 1996 Who need Parents? The effects of childcare and early education on children in Britain and USA. London: The IEA Health and Welfare Unit

A session with Neil and Clive – Methodology

The session today I found useful, I think I found it helpful as it allows collaborative work to be carried out on our Independent Studies. It allows me to gain some reassurance about my ideas and work. The sessions have a sense of ‘togetherness’ about them and I feel this to be good as it shows to me that I am not alone on this project.

Literature Review

  • What is it you’re reading?
  • Who wrote it?
  • Why did they write it?
  • When did they write it?
  • Select and sample research
  • Page numbers for citations and Journals needed

The decision NOT to read is as important as the decision to read a piece of text.

Methodologies

  • Who has researched into the area before
  • Epistemology – the study of knowledge
  • Why would it be researched in this way?
  • Positivistic/ Interpretivistic
  • Do ‘you’ want to find a definite answer or discussing what is already known and creating further areas of study? Exploratory versus Explanatory
  • The ‘thinking’ behind the research
  • Why are ‘you’ choosing this particular method?
  • Ontology
  • Nomological/ Positivist – could be followed by everyone, underlying laws
  • Idiographic/ interpretivistic – expect to see differences between people’s views (specific understanding)
  • Empirical – doing, creating your own research. Generating ‘your’ own data
  • Inductive – theory then data
  • Deductive – data then theory
  • Reliability/ Truth/ Validity/ Collection
  • Power
  • Ethics – why one way and not another/ be critical and reflective

In your appendix you can explain methodology and do a paragraph explaining certain aspects of the area, for example, paradigms.

Question and Answer

Rachel: If we use an online journal do we have to state in our references that it was found online or can we just simply give the full reference of the journal if it is available?

Clive: You do not have to state that it was found online; you do not have to actually touch the journal!

Useful question that I would have and have already thought to myself!

Check out Bibliographies advice on WebCT

Reading………

Campbell, R (1996) Literacy in Nursery Education. Staffordshire: Trentham Books Limited

  • Looks into the role of storytelling in the classroom. The advantages more than the disadvantages.
  • The teacher and the play are relationship – how space is relevant in the child’s education

    FOUND THE ABOVE TO NOT BE RELEVANT

Gilkes, J (1987) Developing Nursery Education. Milton Keynes: Open University Press

  • Why parents decide upon nurseries
  • The purpose of nurseries from when they originally established to their purposes today.
  • How nurseries carry out their purposes. What activities they carry and why.
  • A structure/curriculum for nurseries
  • The need to prepare the child for school.

Anthony Giddens “prized child” http://old.lse.ac.uk/collections/meetthedirector/pdf/23-Jan-02.pdf

  • Demographic changes
  • Infertility
  • Changing patterns of the family unit

A summary of the Giddens talk:

Politics within relationships, the need to have a democracy within a relationship, an equal balance between partners and in decisions about children. The shift of family tradition: “you cannot form a type of family which is so different from traditional families and still call it a family. I think this school of thought, which tends to be, but is not inevitably, linked to rightist political positions, would say that the family is in a state of crisis.”
The “prized child”, children are seen as more precious in comparison to tradition where there were many children in one family and they would carry on their fathers work or become house wives. Traditionally, children would contribute to the “economic unit” of the family. However, nowadays family is seen more as “a set of relationships based much more upon communication and especially based upon emotional communication.”
Partners in relationships: same sex, is this considered a family if they decide to have children? Is it morally right? There are concerns here with society and culture. The relationships that same sex partners have with their children; who takes on the role of the mother and of the father? Do they have roles?
14/11/2006

Today, Claire had organised a session of ‘Accessing on-line Journals’ with Emily from the Didsbury Library. I found it extremely helpful and it will definitely benefit me in the researching of my Independent Study. Although there were handouts given out, below are a few points I took away from the session:
  • Select key words from working title. For example, Language and Policy: An Investigation into the construction of Nursery Provision (the words in bold, I would choose as my key words).
  • Think of different words that mean the same thing. For example, Language could be vocabulary or meaning. Nursery Provision could be childcare or education etc.
  • Think about different endings: Truncation. For example, Management will only look for articles containing the word management. Therefore use the stem ‘manag’ and then place an asterisk (*) this will then look for all articles containing ‘manag’ and all its endings.
  • Three or four searches may need to be carried out on different databases to find relevant journals.
  • It is easier to access when on a MMU campus.
  • Check out over subjects as well as Communications as there could be other relevant articles in their databases. For example. Psychology, Social Work etc.

    How to access the Journals within MMU:

    Library – Resources by Subjects or Databases by title (if you know which database you want to use) – Communications – Choose database Eg/ Expanded Academic ASAP International – Advanced Search

    The Find It button will search Manchester Metropolitan University to see if a hard copy is available in the library.

    I found Emily to be very easy to talk to and approachable, this helps as if I am struggling at anytime in the library; I know that support is there. Thank you Claire!!!
Reflection

In the past two weeks, I have received bad news about one member of family and therefore my Independent Study has been affected and my concentration on my work has suffered. I was not able to work as my mind was not focused and as a result anything that I would have produced would not have been up to my normal standard and much that I had read would not have properly registered in my brain. However, I have to be able to prioritise certain aspects of my life. I have to set out specific goals when it comes to my Independent Study. I will have to decide what needs to be done and do one bit at a time. For example, in relation with my reading and researching which is the stage I am in at the moment, I will read a certain article or piece of text, summarise it and make a full reference and then blog it, so that I have all my information to hand when I come to write up the final piece. Still at this stage, I am worried that my Independent Study will be affected and that I will not achieve the grade I am capable of achieving because of other factors that are playing on my mind. I am hoping that this will change and I can gain a more positive attitude towards my work and towards my mum’s health.

Monday, October 23, 2006

Reading, reading, reading........

Now that the proposal is completed, I am going to concentrate on reading and researching in order to create a theoretical structure that will uphold my empirical study. As stated in a previous post, there are certain books and sources which I intend to read. I will be making a list of useful quotes that I will publish on my blog so that I have access to them at any stage throughout my Independent Study.

Clive has also lent me the book Lakoff, G 2004 Don't think of an Elephant! Know your Values and Frame the Debate. Vermont: Chelsea Green Publishing which I have been looking at over the weekend. Although not directly looking at the language used in childcare, it looks at the use of metaphors and the language involved in politics. This can therefore, be related to my Independent Study. Useful quotes and citings are to follow.....
The proposal is over!!!!

I have submitted by proposal and there are certain reflections that I have made about the whole process of writing the proposal:
  • Do not let stress prevent me from writing a piece of work, even if it is only 100 words.
  • If I allow myself enough time, I will be able to have days where I may not be able to write and it will be fine to walk away from the piece of work and return to it on another day or at a later time.
  • Place the deadline several days or a week before it has to be handed in, this will give me time to have people read over my piece and I can improve and make changes before the final deadline.
  • Everything I read or every thought that comes to mind, make sure I write down and if it is a quote make sure that I reference properly where the source is from so that I have all references to hand when I come to write up my proposal.
  • Do not be afraid to become creative in my writing. For instance creating appendices, seperating my writing into headings to allow for the piece to be organised and formal.

I was pleased with my proposal, yet I would want to control my time more effeciently next time, to gain not only all the help I possibly can, but for my stress levels to remain at a healthy state!!!

Friday, October 20, 2006

Below is the literature I have already read and explored within my Independent Study.

Biber, B, 1984 Early Education and Psychological Development, New Haven: Yale University Press

Campbell, R, 1996 Literacy in Nursery Education, Staffordshire: Trentham Books Limited

Gilkes, J, 1987 Developing Nursery Education, Milton Keynes: Open University Press

Hurst, V & Joseph, J, 1998 Supporting Early Learning: The way forward, Buckingham: Open University Press

http://www.itscotland.org.uk/earlyyears/about/curriculum/framechildren3to5.asp

Pahl, K, 1999 Transformations: Children’s meaning making in a nursery, Staffordshire: Trentham Books Limited

http://www.standards.dfes.gov.uk/primary/publications/foundation_stage/940463

http://www.underfives.co.uk/birthtothree.htm

Vickerius, M & Sandberg, A (2006) Early Child Development and Care. The Significance of play and the environment around play176 (2) 207-217


Below is a list of reading material I will want to read to develop my understanding for the Independent Study.

Bell, J, 1999 Doing a research project: a guide for first time researchers in education, Third Edition. Buckingham: Open University Press

Garvey, C, 1990 Play, Cambridge: Harvard University New York Press

Hurst, V & Joseph, J, 1998 Supporting Early Learning: The way forward, Buckingham: Open University Press

Jenkinson, S, 2002 The Genius of Play: Celebrating the spirit of childhood (Early Years), UK: Hawthorn Press Ltd

http://www.literacytrust.org.uk/Database/earlydebate.html#too The Independent article ‘ATL calls for formal schooling to start at six’ 17th April 2003

Oldfield, L, 2002 Free to learn: Introducing Steiner Waldorf Early Childhood Education, Hawthorn Press

Sandberg, A (2003) Early Child Development and Care. Play memories and identity 173 (2-3) 207-221

Ward, L ‘Free nursery scheme could be bad for young children, says study’ the Guardian, 4th October 2005 in http://society.guardian.co.uk/children/story/0/1584359,00html

Whitehead, M, 1999 Supporting language and literacy development in the Early Years, Buckingham: Open University Press

This is just a preliminary reading list as my ideas and study develops, so will my literature reading list.
Independent Study Proposal

Working Title: Language and policy: an Investigation into the construction of Nursery Provision

Supervisor: Clive McGoun

I look upon my Independent Study as a journey, in which my direction will change through the development of my thoughts and research. In this sense, my aims for the study may alter themselves throughout the process. In these beginning stages, my aims are primarily concerned with the relationship between language and its meaning within a nursery policy document, which ultimately leads onto the relevance of this particular policy, how this document is perceived as well as put into action in a nursery environment.
During the Communication course, I have become increasingly involved with the Human aspect and now want to complete my University experience as a Human Communication graduate. My study refers to the education and understanding amongst nursery school children and this therefore relates to their communication on both an intra and interpersonal level. As Biber considers the “growth of language” within a child is “part of the development of human communication”. (1984: 106) In relation to my Independent Study, if a child’s language and education is growing within a nursery, consequently this is connected with their overall human communication. Not only am I looking at the communication between the people involved in nursery provision, but also the way the language is communicated from policy to action. How the words in a document are communicated into educational activities in a classroom.
The reason for carrying out this study is due to me working in nurseries for the past two years and discovering a world of frameworks, policies and pre-school learning. I was surprised to learn that nurseries have a curriculum to consider when caring for children. In addition to this, simplistic lesson plans and specific tasks are created to develop a child’s understanding and education. I believed a nursery to be considered as a safe environment for a child to be in whilst his/her parents were at work or similar to the opinion of Gilkes, who stated that the nursery was seen as “a helping hand” to those who were “new or struggling” as a parent. (1987: 3) Yet, I had established a new reason, that children may be attending nursery to begin their education and to gain and develop life skills. This led me to read a policy document called ‘Birth to Three Matters’. This document outlines what is expected of both the workers and the children in a nursery environment and how a child’s learning and understanding can begin at such a young age. This got me to thinking about the role of education and play and the relationship between the two within a nursery. My ideas have developed from this personal interest to the questioning behind the making of these policy documents.
In recent years there has been much debate about the benefits that a child may or may not have in attending nurseries. Many believe that a child will more likely adapt to Year 1 at an infant school if they have begun their education at a nursery stage. As outlined in The Importance of pre-school education,

“Two children using a plastic cup to fill a bucket with water may be involved in counting how many cups are required to fill the bucket, in discussing the results with each other and in agreeing to take turns. They may therefore be developing mathematical, language and social learning.” (www.itscotland.org)

These skills having been established in a nursery will then benefit and allow the child to have a head start when they begin at Key Stage One. Whilst others, similar to the article posted on the 30th January 2004 believe that pre-school children “are not receiving the play-based education they are supposed to because of pressure to prepare for more formal learning in later years” (www.literacytrust.org) through researching into the language being used in the documents, it will be interesting to see how much pressure these policies place on nurseries to enhance nursery learning. This therefore leads onto a political interest into how the Foundation Stage Curriculum and ‘Birth to Three Matters’ impacts on a child’s transition into Key Stage One and the conflicting views of professionals and how this theory works in practice.
Much literature has been written about the subject of nurseries and their role in the development of a child’s education. When I first decided upon this particular area of study, I found that there was too much written about the matter, therefore I created a number of themes or specific topic areas which allowed me to devise questions and from here I will be able to discover what I need to read, see Appendix A. I felt this to be more beneficial for my study as it allowed me to confine my ideas on such a broad subject matter. As I have already quoted above there are many opinions and an on-going debate about the framework used within nurseries. Many of the books encourage educational development in a pre-school environment, yet many articles state figures and reports against the curriculum and claim that children are missing out on their chance to play. This literature will be discussed and expanded within the section of my Literature Review of my final Independent Study. In the Appendices, one will be able to see the literature I have read about already and the academic text I want to read throughout the process. I also feel that as I continue on this journey, my questions may change or develop into further questions being asked; in this case my literature will expand to gain additional answers and knowledge.
As stated in my title my Independent Study is an investigation, the purpose of carrying out the project is not to decide whether it is right or wrong to begin a child’s education in nursery, but to discuss and explore the opposing views and to look in further detail at the ‘Birth to Three Matters’ policy document, to see how its framework is beneficial to children. I feel it necessary to emphasise the words how and why, as they are two expressions that will continuously be used throughout my whole Independent Study. Already, I have many questions and I believe as I develop in my project, I may not discover answers but create further questions instead. However, I still consider this to be positive progress as I am ‘investigating into’, not creating a definite answer. Through conducting this research study I am making myself aware of the attitudes and meaning behind Nursery Provision.
After completing this whole process, I believe that the results I will receive from the information I have gained through my research methods will show if my study has achieved its purpose. I am hoping to gain a better understanding of the policy document ‘Birth to Three Matters’. How it is put into practice within a nursery setting and why the policy is considered to be fundamental in a child’s development of education. I do think there will still be questions left unanswered or unexplored at the end of conducting the study. Yet, I do not believe this to be a sign that my study has not achieved its intention. In contrast, I see it as my project has developed and allows for further investigation at a later stage.
My Independent Study takes on both a theoretical as well as an empirical approach. From a theoretical perspective I am exploring into the literature already written around and about the subject matter. I will be taking a section of text from the ‘Birth to Three Matters’ policy document and seeing how the lexis used influences the activities being carried out in the nursery. However, from an empirical viewpoint I am hoping to undergo a type of ethnographic study. According to the opinion of Amy McCleverty,

“Ethnography is a traditional method of sociology and cultural anthropology. It involves the study of people performing activities and interacting in complex social settings in order to obtain a qualitative understanding of these interactions.” (http://pages.cpsc)

In conducting my project, my ethnographic study will involve the undertaking of formal interviews and observation.
As you will see in Appendix C, there is much literature written about the subject of Nursery Provision and by reading through the research I am expanding upon my knowledge as well as investigating and developing my initial questions and ideas. The information I receive will allow me to progress in my journey. The research methods I have chosen to adopt when carrying out my ethnographic study allow me to see how the policy document is transformed from words to action in its social context and how valuable and effective the framework is on a child’s understanding. As McCleverty goes onto say “the objective of completing an ethnographic study is to identify and highlight routine practices, problems and possibilities for development within a given activity or setting.” (http://pages.cpsc) In relation to my study through the use of interviews and observation, I am able to recognise and establish certain routines that the children go through and outline the advantages and disadvantages that arise from the ‘Birth to Three Matters’ framework. An academic book that I will be referring to when conducting my research methods is: Doing a Research Project: A guide for first time researchers in education written by Judith Bell. Bell outlines the importance and gives a specific layout of how research methods such as interviewing can benefit one in carrying out a study. This will be detailed further as set out in the section of my Research Methods in my Independent Study.
The main difficulty I will encounter when embarking upon my Independent Study is the ethical side of being involved and researching amongst children. There are many acts such as the Child Protection and Data Protection Act that could limit my access to both inside a nursery environment and documents concerning children and nurseries. I am at an advantage where I have worked with children and therefore have already access to several nurseries. I am also in possession of an Enhanced Disclosure Form which allows me to enter into a nursery or a school. When carrying out observations on children or in a setting where children may be present, I would have to gain parents consent. This can be done through proposing a letter that could be sent out to parents explaining to them, my reasoning for carrying out work within the nursery and my intention of my Independent Study.
Another problem that could arise is the time constraint that I have on conducting this study. Due to my proposed study being such a vast subject matter, I could continuously create themes and questions around the area. However, through already creating specific topic areas I am giving myself a structured framework and as I have said before, I am not looking to answer all my questions, but rather explore and investigate into the chosen themes in order to further my knowledge about the construction of nursery provision.

Monday, October 16, 2006

The next step......

I am now in the stage of writing my proposal; I have created a monthly timetable on Microsoft Word and am in the process of filling in the days to give myself a structure for the Independent Study. Through creating a timetable, I am giving myself a sense of direction, although the deadlines and days may alter and change, it still allows for me to stay focused and not lose my way in a couple of months!

I am slightly apprehensive about writing up my proposal; I think it is because it will be my first assessed piece of work since I have come back to University after the summer. I have many bullet points and drafts on Word as well as in hand-written form; I just need to put it all together. I have had my sister read through some sections of my proposal to gain some advice and to check that the piece reads well. Plus she is very helpful to speak to as she has recently just become a University graduate, so it has not been long since she was in my position writing her Independent Study! By Thursday I am hoping that both Clive, my sister and a house mate will have read through my proposal before I submit the overall piece. My main concern at the moment is the literature review, reviews are not my strongest skill probably because I have not had the chance to write many, I am not sure as to how it is included in the proposal with such a short number of words, I will speak to Clive about this issue!
Themes and Topic areas

After writing my mini essay, I have created themes/ topic areas in which I can place my questions into categories:

Provision (the need to provide)
The nursery being seen as a company or a business that provides a service

What is the service?

Looking after and caring for a child?

To develop and begin a child’s education?

Is this service more beneficial than keeping a child at home?


Social Skills (Education = Learning Environment)
Concept of sharing

Is sharing educational?

Can this concept only be achieved in a nursery environment?

Is there relationship between nurseries and only children?


Use of Lexis (The word Birth)
Babies do not come straight out of a mother’s womb into a nursery


What are the youngest age nursery take children?


Is the word Birth quick and easier to say?


When does a child’s education begin?


Do people believe that these document’s help children?


Do the documents actually benefit the child?


Do the documents just uphold a type of structure for the nursery?

(The word matters)
The connotations of this word implies that it is vital

If a child gets taken out or changes nursery or starts at a later stage are they at a disadvantage?

Does this mean that a child is missing out on a vital part of their education?

The role of the Imagination
Imagination used in play

Learning through imagination and play – Is this more effective than carrying out classroom tasks?

Imagination

What does it mean?

Where does it come from?

How is it used?

Is it an internal process? That is used by an individual on an intrapersonal level

If this is so, why is it being used in context with educating a group of nursery children?

Can you tell/teach somebody how to use their imagination?

Do education and imagination have a relationship?

What does the language mean or what is the policy trying to convey when placing education and imagination in the same document?


The word construction
· Dictatorship
1. Ofsted Inspections
2. Sure Start Meetings
· Framework
1. Laying out requirements for nursery education


Connotations of the word policy
· Ruling and obeying
1. Due to the document being associated with the Government is this why is it considered important?
2. Does the document only have a sense of ‘power’ because it is used with the word policy?

· Advice and Guidelines
1. How is the document perceived?
2. Is it just a framework?